‘I, Tonya’ Takes On The Media’s Messy Relationship With Female Athletes
Olympic figure skater Tonya Harding is a household name, and not because of her talent and accomplishments on the ice.
The new movie “I, Tonya” stars Margot Robbie (“The Wolf of Wall Street”) as the infamous Harding, coming to terms with her abusive mother (Allison Janney) and blue-collar upbringing, while navigating the world of competitive ice skating. Harding, known for her athleticism and big jumps, became the first American woman to land a triple axel during the short program in 1991. The maneuver is so difficult that the filmmakers of “I, Tonya” had to use computer-generated imaging to recreate it for the film, altering footage of a skater performing a double axel instead.
The movie also explores how Harding became one of the most famous villains in sports after her ex-husband was implicated in the brutal beating of fellow competitor, Nancy Kerrigan.
"I think it was easier to put Tonya as the villain because she just wasn't the image that the figure skating world wanted,” Robbie told Refinery29 at a recent screening for the film. “I've watched every video of her skating like a thousand times over, and the number of times they comment on the class of family she comes from — it should just be about the skating, but they'll be like 'Here's Tonya Harding, girl from the wrong side of the tracks!'”
Robbie noted that she felt Kerrigan was also unfairly portrayed, as the media cast her as the “elite” queen to underdog Harding, when in reality, Kerrigan grew up in a blue-collar family, too.
"I think the media likes to pit two women against each other, and people eat that up,” added screenwriter Steven Rogers.
It raises a powerful question: Does the media reinforce a good vs. evil narrative that reduces strong female athletes into caricatures of themselves? How different might Harding’s background story have been treated had she been a male skater or perhaps an ice hockey player? Would her grit and aggression on and off the ice have been celebrated?
The answer is likely yes, according to recent studies, which show that the amount of media coverage and representations of female athletes has actually worsened in the last 25 years.
Cynthia Frisby, an associate professor of strategic communications at the University of Missouri, found that coverage of athletes participating in the 2016 Olympics as compared to the 2012 Olympics had become more sexist and more racist in her study published in the Journal of Mass Communication and Journalism in June.
Frisby and lead author Kara Allen analyzed 723 newspaper and magazine articles covering the 2012 and 2016 Olympics. The biggest increases came when referring to women as second-class citizens or projecting restrictive gender roles. “Results seem to imply that coverage of the female athletes focused on policing behaviors acceptable for the female gender and whether or not women were adhering to these expectations,” Frisby wrote.
As for that famous attack on Kerrigan, Harding has always said she did not know about it, though she pleaded guilty to conspiracy to hinder an investigation and was barred from United States Figure Skating Association competitions, something Robbie thinks was an unfair punishment.
She hopes this film and other female-driven films and television projects on the slate at her new production company, Lucky Chap, will help change the narrative around how women are portrayed, not only in sports media, but in media and society at large.
“I can kind of feel that this young generation as we enter the industry, we're pointing out the things that we don't agree with, and we wanna change it,” she said. “It is about moving forward and finding what we're gonna fix and actually doing something about it instead of talking about it.”
Share image courtesy of NEON/30West.
Serena Williams just exposed one of the most sexist double standards in all of sports. The closer you look the more unbelievable it becomes.
Serena Williams responds to backlash about her catsuit by competing in a tutu “The policing of women’s bodies must end.”
Week One Of The NFL Preseason Brings Player Protests And Outrage From The President Two players from the Miami Dolphins kneeled during the national anthem
Team Fox Athletes Race Toward A Cure For Parkinson’s Disease “If I can do it, anybody can do it.”
Hope Solo Believes The High Cost Of Youth Soccer Is Hurting The State Of The Game Club soccer can cost families $17,000 a year, according to a recent report.
Surfer, New Mom, And Philanthropist Alana Blanchard Wants To Help Young Female Surfers Realize Their Dreams The cost for young surfers to compete can be daunting without major sponsors and brands to help with travel and contest fees, so she created the Alana Blanchard Foundation.
‘Workers Cup’ Film Highlights The Complicated Preparations For The 2022 World Cup In Qatar, workers balance their love of soccer with the burden of treacherous work conditions.
Becky Hammon Becomes The First Female Assistant Head Coach In All 4 Major U.S. Sports She may have a head coaching gig in her sights as well.